Best Stain For Fireplace Mantel Reviews In 2023

Your fireplace mantel is a focal point in your home, and you want it to look good. It can be difficult to choose the best stain for your mantle, especially when there are so many options out there. But don’t worry – we’ve got you covered!

In this article, we’ll discuss the different types of stains available and provide you with a list of the 10 best stains for your fireplace mantel. We’ll also give you five tips on what to look for when buying a stain and explain how to use it safely. Finally, we’ll talk about how to choose the right stain for your fireplace mantel. So read on – and get ready to make your fireplace mantel look beautiful!

Types of Best Stain For Fireplace Mantel

Stain is an important part of maintaining a fireplace mantel’s look and durability. Different types of stains offer unique advantages, depending on the type of wood used. For example, oil-based stains provide rich, deep colors and excellent protection against moisture, while water-based stains are easier to clean up and provide a lighter color with less protection from moisture.

Polyurethane finishes offer excellent protection from scratches and wear but can be difficult to apply evenly. Gel stains are popular for their ease of use, but they provide less protection from moisture than other types of stain. No matter which type of stain you choose, it’s important to follow the manufacturer’s instructions for best results.

List of 10 Best Stain For Fireplace Mantel

When it comes to staining your fireplace mantel, there are many different options available. It can be difficult to decide which one is the best for your particular situation. To make the choice easier, here is a list of the 10 best stains for fireplace mantels:

  1. Minwax Gel Stain: This easy-to-apply stain is great for achieving both light and dark finishes on wood surfaces. It’s ideal for using on fireplace mantels because it’s fast-drying and durable, making it perfect for high traffic areas.
  2. Varathane Wood Stain: This water-based stain offers great coverage and provides a deep color that won’t fade over time. It’s also easy to apply and won’t require any kind of prepping like sanding or priming before you use it.
  3. General Finishes High Performance Water Based Topcoat: This topcoat is perfect if you want a glossy finish on your mantel that will last through many years of use. It’s designed to protect wood from damage while still allowing the natural beauty of the wood grain to show through.
  4. Rustoleum Ultimate Wood Stain: This stain is perfect if you’re looking for an oil-based finish that offers great protection against wear and tear as well as UV radiation from sunlight exposure. The fast drying formula makes it easy to apply with minimal mess, too!
  5. Behr Premium Wood Finish Interior/Exterior Solid Color Stain: This stain offers excellent coverage, so you don’t have to worry about having any streaks or unevenness after applying it to your fireplace mantel. The semi-transparent finish allows some of the natural wood grain texture to show through, but still gives it plenty of color depth and richness.
  6. Zinsser Watertite Waterproofing Wood Finish: If you live in an area where moisture is a concern or if you just want extra protection against water damage, this waterproofing wood finish can help keep your fireplace mantel looking its best no matter what Mother Nature throws at it!
  7. Varathane One Step Oil Based Polyurethane Finish: If you’re looking for long lasting protection with a beautiful sheen, this oil based polyurethane finish is ideal for protecting your mantel from wear and tear while providing superior shine and depth of color at the same time!
  8. Minwax Polycrylic Protective Finish: For those who prefer an acrylic finish without glossy sheen, this protective finish provides a durable crystal clear layer that helps protect against moisture damage as well as scratches and scuffs from everyday use in high traffic areas around your home.
  9. Rustoleum Ultimate Wood Stains & Finishes Semi-Transparent Tintable Neutral Base Gallon Kit: When you need just the right shade of paint for your fireplace mantel but don’t have time to mix colors yourself, this tintable neutral base kit has everything you need in one convenient package! You can easily mix up custom colors with this kit while still enjoying superior protection and durability against wear and tear too!
  10. Thompson’s WaterSeal Semi-Transparent Exterior/Interior Wood Finish Clear Satin Gallon Can: Finally, if you want something with lots of versatility that can be used indoors or outdoors – this clear satin gallon can is perfect! Not only does it provide superior waterproofing protection but also adds subtle color enhancement while still keeping the natural beauty of the wood visible underneath!

5 Things to Consider When BuyingBest Stain For Fireplace Mantel

When shopping for the best stain for your fireplace mantel, there are a few things to consider. The type of stain you choose will depend on the existing finish and the desired look of your mantel. Here are five factors to consider when selecting the best stain for your fireplace mantel:

  1. Color – The color of the stain should match the overall aesthetic of your room, as well as complementing other colors in the space. Consider shades such as chocolate brown, dark walnut, or ebony black to create a classic look that matches almost any decor style.
  2. Finish – Different types of finishes can add texture and depth to your fireplace mantel, giving it a more distinct appearance. Depending on what kind of look you’re going for, you may opt for a glossy finish which will give your mantel an elegant shine or a matte finish that gives off more muted tones.
  3. VOC Levels – Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are chemicals released into the air when certain products are used and can be harmful if inhaled over long periods of time. When selecting a stain for your fireplace mantel, check to make sure it is low VOC or has no VOCs at all to ensure that it does not affect indoor air quality.
  4. Durability – Make sure the stain you select is durable enough to withstand hot temperatures radiating from the fire below as well as everyday wear-and-tear such as dust and dirt accumulation. A water-based polyurethane sealer should provide extra protection against these elements while also making cleaning easier down the line.
  5. Price – Price should always be taken into account when choosing any product because good quality products tend to be more expensive than cheaper counterparts with lower levels of performance or durability. Compare prices among different brands before settling on one that fits both your budget and desired outcome perfectly.

How to Use the Best Stain For Fireplace Mantel

When it comes to applying a stain to the fireplace mantel, you need to make sure that you are using the best stain for the job. Before you start, though, it is important that you understand how to properly use your chosen stain in order to get the best results.

Before anything else, make sure to clean off any existing finishes or residue from the mantel with a mild detergent and warm water. To ensure that no further damage is done during application of the stain, it’s important to sand the wood before staining. This will help create a nice even finish with minimal brush strokes. When sanding, make sure to work with the grain of the wood and use a fine grit sandpaper between 150-220 grit range.

Once your surface is prepped and ready for staining, begin by stirring your stain thoroughly and apply it evenly across your mantel using a foam brush or lint-free cloth. If you are using an oil based product, be sure not to stir too vigorously as this could introduce air bubbles into your mixture which could lead to an uneven finish. Once you have applied an even coat of stain across your fireplace mantel, allow it ample time (follow product instructions) to dry completely before applying additional coats if necessary.

Finally, once all of your coats have been applied and allowed adequate drying time, seal your mantel with a clear coat sealant or varnish of your choice in order to protect the finish from wear and tear over time. Always follow product instructions when applying sealants or varnishes as failure to do so may result in unsatisfactory results.

By following these steps for proper application of stains on fireplace mantels, you can ensure that you get beautiful results every time!

How to Choose Best Stain For Fireplace Mantel

Choosing the best stain for a fireplace mantel is important, as it will protect the mantel from wear and tear, as well as add to its beauty. There are several factors that must be taken into consideration in order to make an informed decision on which type of stain to use.

First, consider the type of wood used on the mantel. Different woods require specific types of stains with different properties in order to bring out their best features. For example, mahogany requires a darker stain than pine does. Darker woods may also require a sealant that can help protect them against moisture and wear.

Second, think about your home’s existing decor and color scheme when selecting a stain for your fireplace mantel. You may want to choose something that will complement the furniture or flooring in the room. It’s important to note that some stains may not show up well on certain types of wood or if they are too light or dark compared to the other elements in the room.

Third, determine how much work you’re willing to put into applying and maintaining the stain on your mantel. Some stains are easier to apply and require less maintenance than others. Water-based stains are usually easier to apply but need more regular upkeep; oil-based stains often last longer but require more effort during application and removal when needed.

Fourth, look at how long you plan on keeping your mantle stained with its current color before making a decision on which type of stain to purchase. If you plan on keeping your mantle for many years, then you want to ensure that you use a product that won’t fade over time so it retains its original beauty for years to come.

Fifth and finally, consider how much money you’re willing to spend on purchasing and applying the stain for your fireplace mantel when making a final selection. Depending on the size of your mantle and type of wood used, costs can vary significantly between different brands and types of products available in stores or online retailers. Make sure you consider all these factors before deciding which product is right for you!


In conclusion, choosing the best stain for your fireplace mantel is an important decision that can make or break your finished look. It’s important to consider factors like the wood type, color, and finish desired when selecting a stain. There are many different types of stains available, with each offering its own unique advantages and disadvantages. Knowing which one is right for you will help ensure that your fireplace mantel looks just how you want it to. With the right knowledge and selection process, you can find the perfect stain to make your fireplace mantel shine!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top